Talk:THIS - Revision history

172.18.0.2: /* Does this investment report violate any copyright laws? */

2022-07-17T09:50:37Z

Does this investment report violate any copyright laws?

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:50, 17 July 2022
Line 23:		Line 23:
	On the Stockhub platform, the reason for using the work is to review the work itself and, ultimately, the investment to which the work relates (i.e. for review purposes), and, therefore, it is the view of Stockhub that using the work falls into the fair dealing category provided that 1) the used work is accompanied by a sufficient acknowledgement and 2) the work has been made available to the public.		On the Stockhub platform, the reason for using the work is to review the work itself and, ultimately, the investment to which the work relates (i.e. for review purposes), and, therefore, it is the view of Stockhub that using the work falls into the fair dealing category provided that 1) the used work is accompanied by a sufficient acknowledgement and 2) the work has been made available to the public.

	It is the view of Stockhub that while an offer to invest in a private investment ~~in the UK and in many other jurisdictions~~ can only be lawfully made to private members only (i.e. not to the public), the copyrighted work to which the investment relates has been made available to the public. Furthermore, it is the view of Stockhub that the acknowledgement that accompanies the used work is sufficient.		It is the view of Stockhub that while in the UK and in many other jurisdictions, an offer to invest in a private investment can only be lawfully made to private members only (i.e. not to the public), the copyrighted work to which the investment relates has been made available to the public. Furthermore, it is the view of Stockhub that the acknowledgement that accompanies the used work is sufficient.

	The main purpose of the original work is to enable people to raise funds for their companies faster, and the purpose of the new work is to enable people to make better investment decisions. Accordingly, it is the view of Stockhub that the target audience of the works and the core benefit of the works, and, ultimately, the market of the works, are significantly different. Therefore, it is also the opinion of Stockhub that using the work does not act as a substitute for the work; if anything, it acts as a complement. It's worth nothing that the price of the original work is zero (i.e. there is no fee), and, therefore, the likeliness of the owner of the work losing revenue from the Stockhub platform using the work is zero; the owner of the work makes money from investment commissions when its clients successfully raise funds.		The main purpose of the original work is to enable people to raise funds for their companies faster, and the purpose of the new work is to enable people to make better investment decisions. Accordingly, it is the view of Stockhub that the target audience of the works and the core benefit of the works, and, ultimately, the market of the works, are significantly different. Therefore, it is also the opinion of Stockhub that using the work does not act as a substitute for the work; if anything, it acts as a complement. It's worth nothing that the price of the original work is zero (i.e. there is no fee), and, therefore, the likeliness of the owner of the work losing revenue from the Stockhub platform using the work is zero; the owner of the work makes money from investment commissions when its clients successfully raise funds.

172.18.0.2: /* Is this investment report a financial promotion? */

2022-07-17T09:47:23Z

Is this investment report a financial promotion?

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:47, 17 July 2022
Line 8:		Line 8:
	For a communication to be considered a financial promotion, the communication must contain an element of invitation or inducement, amongst other things<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/3.html</ref>; for a communication to be considered an invitation or inducement, the communication must “have the purpose or intent of leading a person to engage in investment activity".<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref>		For a communication to be considered a financial promotion, the communication must contain an element of invitation or inducement, amongst other things<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/3.html</ref>; for a communication to be considered an invitation or inducement, the communication must “have the purpose or intent of leading a person to engage in investment activity".<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref>

	In relation to the said report/communication, the communicator of the communication is anonymous, and, therefore, the purpose of the communicator, and the purpose of the communication itself, is unknown. The FCA recognises that the matter cannot be without doubt.<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref> That said, the purpose of the Stockhub platform is to help a person to make better investment decisions (i.e. it’s not lead a person to engage in investment activity). Indeed, the purpose of the platform is reflected in the platform's monetization strategy (i.e. donations and advertising). In other words, the owner of the platform (i.e. Stockhub Limited) does not benefit from a person engaging in investment activities in the said investment; the owner benefits from a person making better investment decisions.		In relation to the said report/communication, the communicator of the communication is anonymous, and, therefore, the purpose of the communicator, and the purpose of the communication itself, is unknown. The FCA recognises that the matter cannot be without doubt.<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref> That said, the purpose of the Stockhub platform is to help a person to make better investment decisions (i.e. it’s not to lead a person to engage in investment activity). Indeed, the purpose of the platform is reflected in the platform's monetization strategy (i.e. donations and advertising). In other words, the owner of the platform (i.e. Stockhub Limited) does not benefit from a person engaging in investment activities in the said investment; the owner benefits from a person making better investment decisions.

	Accordingly, it is the view of the Stockhub company that the said investment report is NOT a financial promotion.		Accordingly, it is the view of the Stockhub company that the said investment report is NOT a financial promotion.

172.18.0.2: /* Does this investment report violate any copyright laws? */

2022-07-09T09:07:41Z

Does this investment report violate any copyright laws?

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:07, 9 July 2022
Line 14:		Line 14:
	== Does this investment report violate any copyright laws? ==		== Does this investment report violate any copyright laws? ==

	According to the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, "Fair dealing with a work for the purpose of criticism or review, of that or another work or of a performance of a work, does not infringe any copyright in the work provided that it is accompanied by a sufficient acknowledgement (unless this would be impossible for reasons of practicality or otherwise) and provided that the work has been made available to the ~~public~~.		According to the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, "Fair dealing with a work for the purpose of criticism or review, of that or another work or of a performance of a work, does not infringe any copyright in the work provided that it is accompanied by a sufficient acknowledgement (unless this would be impossible for reasons of practicality or otherwise) and provided that the work has been made available to the public”.

	Factors that have been identified by the courts as relevant in determining whether a particular dealing with a work is fair include:		Factors that have been identified by the courts as relevant in determining whether a particular dealing with a work is fair include:
Line 27:		Line 27:
	The main purpose of the original work is to enable people to raise funds for their companies faster, and the purpose of the new work is to enable people to make better investment decisions. Accordingly, it is the view of Stockhub that the target audience of the works and the core benefit of the works, and, ultimately, the market of the works, are significantly different. Therefore, it is also the opinion of Stockhub that using the work does not act as a substitute for the work; if anything, it acts as a complement. It's worth nothing that the price of the original work is zero (i.e. there is no fee), and, therefore, the likeliness of the owner of the work losing revenue from the Stockhub platform using the work is zero; the owner of the work makes money from investment commissions when its clients successfully raise funds.		The main purpose of the original work is to enable people to raise funds for their companies faster, and the purpose of the new work is to enable people to make better investment decisions. Accordingly, it is the view of Stockhub that the target audience of the works and the core benefit of the works, and, ultimately, the market of the works, are significantly different. Therefore, it is also the opinion of Stockhub that using the work does not act as a substitute for the work; if anything, it acts as a complement. It's worth nothing that the price of the original work is zero (i.e. there is no fee), and, therefore, the likeliness of the owner of the work losing revenue from the Stockhub platform using the work is zero; the owner of the work makes money from investment commissions when its clients successfully raise funds.

	It is the view of Stockhub that in order to conduct an accurate review of the work (i.e. the financial promotion) and, ultimately, the investment to which the work relates (i.e. THIS), the communication of the whole work is required, and, therefore, the amount of the work ~~taken~~ by the communicator is reasonable and appropriate.		It is the view of Stockhub that in order to conduct an accurate review of the work (i.e. the financial promotion) and, ultimately, the investment to which the work relates (i.e. THIS), the communication of the whole work is required, and, therefore, the amount of the work used by the communicator on the Stockhub platform is reasonable and appropriate.

	It's worth noting that facts cannot be copyrighted, so it is the view of Stockhub that even if a fact is not made available to the public (i.e. the fact is made available to the private community only), the fact cannot be copyrighted, and, therefore, using the fact is permissible.		It's worth noting that facts cannot be copyrighted, so it is the view of Stockhub that even if a fact is not made available to the public (i.e. the fact is made available to the private community only), the fact cannot be copyrighted, and, therefore, using the fact is permissible.

>Crowdcube: /* Is this investment report a financial promotion? */

2022-07-02T11:34:15Z

Is this investment report a financial promotion?

← Older revision		Revision as of 12:34, 2 July 2022
Line 8:		Line 8:
	For a communication to be considered a financial promotion, the communication must contain an element of invitation or inducement, amongst other things<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/3.html</ref>; for a communication to be considered an invitation or inducement, the communication must “have the purpose or intent of leading a person to engage in investment activity".<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref>		For a communication to be considered a financial promotion, the communication must contain an element of invitation or inducement, amongst other things<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/3.html</ref>; for a communication to be considered an invitation or inducement, the communication must “have the purpose or intent of leading a person to engage in investment activity".<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref>

	In relation to the said report/communication, the communicator of the communication is anonymous, and, therefore, the purpose of the communicator, and the purpose of the communication itself, is unknown. The FCA recognises that the matter cannot be without doubt.<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref> That said, the purpose of the Stockhub platform is to help a person to make better investment decisions (i.e. it’s not lead a person to engage in investment activity). Indeed, the purpose of the platform is reflected in the platform's monetization strategy (i.e. donations). In other words, the owner of the platform (i.e. Stockhub Limited) does not benefit from a person engaging in investment activities in the said investment; the owner benefits from a person making better investment decisions.		In relation to the said report/communication, the communicator of the communication is anonymous, and, therefore, the purpose of the communicator, and the purpose of the communication itself, is unknown. The FCA recognises that the matter cannot be without doubt.<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref> That said, the purpose of the Stockhub platform is to help a person to make better investment decisions (i.e. it’s not lead a person to engage in investment activity). Indeed, the purpose of the platform is reflected in the platform's monetization strategy (i.e. donations and advertising). In other words, the owner of the platform (i.e. Stockhub Limited) does not benefit from a person engaging in investment activities in the said investment; the owner benefits from a person making better investment decisions.

	Accordingly, it is the view of the Stockhub company that the said investment report is NOT a financial promotion.		Accordingly, it is the view of the Stockhub company that the said investment report is NOT a financial promotion.

172.18.0.2: /* Does this investment report violate any copyright laws? */

2022-07-02T09:59:08Z

Does this investment report violate any copyright laws?

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:59, 2 July 2022
Line 23:		Line 23:
	On the Stockhub platform, the reason for using the work is to review the work itself and, ultimately, the investment to which the work relates (i.e. for review purposes), and, therefore, it is the view of Stockhub that using the work falls into the fair dealing category provided that 1) the used work is accompanied by a sufficient acknowledgement and 2) the work has been made available to the public.		On the Stockhub platform, the reason for using the work is to review the work itself and, ultimately, the investment to which the work relates (i.e. for review purposes), and, therefore, it is the view of Stockhub that using the work falls into the fair dealing category provided that 1) the used work is accompanied by a sufficient acknowledgement and 2) the work has been made available to the public.

	It is the view of Stockhub that while ~~the~~ offer to invest in the ~~investment is~~ to private members only (i.e. not to the public), the copyrighted work to which the investment relates has been made available to the public. Furthermore, it is the view of Stockhub that the acknowledgement that accompanies the used work is sufficient.		It is the view of Stockhub that while an offer to invest in a private investment in the UK and in many other jurisdictions can only be lawfully made to private members only (i.e. not to the public), the copyrighted work to which the investment relates has been made available to the public. Furthermore, it is the view of Stockhub that the acknowledgement that accompanies the used work is sufficient.

	The main purpose of the original work is to enable people to raise funds for their companies faster, and the purpose of the new work is to enable people to make better investment decisions. Accordingly, it is the view of Stockhub that the target audience of the works and the core benefit of the works, and, ultimately, the market of the works, are significantly different. Therefore, it is also the opinion of Stockhub that using the work does not act as a substitute for the work; if anything, it acts as a complement. It's worth nothing that the price of the original work is zero (i.e. there is no fee), and, therefore, the likeliness of the owner of the work losing revenue from the Stockhub platform using the work is zero; the owner of the work makes money from investment commissions when its clients successfully raise funds.		The main purpose of the original work is to enable people to raise funds for their companies faster, and the purpose of the new work is to enable people to make better investment decisions. Accordingly, it is the view of Stockhub that the target audience of the works and the core benefit of the works, and, ultimately, the market of the works, are significantly different. Therefore, it is also the opinion of Stockhub that using the work does not act as a substitute for the work; if anything, it acts as a complement. It's worth nothing that the price of the original work is zero (i.e. there is no fee), and, therefore, the likeliness of the owner of the work losing revenue from the Stockhub platform using the work is zero; the owner of the work makes money from investment commissions when its clients successfully raise funds.

172.18.0.2: /* Is this investment report a financial promotion? */

2022-07-02T09:54:03Z

Is this investment report a financial promotion?

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:54, 2 July 2022
Line 8:		Line 8:
	For a communication to be considered a financial promotion, the communication must contain an element of invitation or inducement, amongst other things<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/3.html</ref>; for a communication to be considered an invitation or inducement, the communication must “have the purpose or intent of leading a person to engage in investment activity".<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref>		For a communication to be considered a financial promotion, the communication must contain an element of invitation or inducement, amongst other things<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/3.html</ref>; for a communication to be considered an invitation or inducement, the communication must “have the purpose or intent of leading a person to engage in investment activity".<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref>

	~~Here~~, the communicator of the communication is anonymous, and, therefore, the purpose of the communicator, and the purpose of the communication itself, is unknown. The FCA recognises that the matter cannot be without doubt.<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref> That said, the purpose of the Stockhub platform is to help a person to make better investment decisions (i.e. it’s not lead a person to engage in investment activity). Indeed, the purpose of the platform is reflected in the platform's monetization strategy (i.e. donations). In other words, the owner of the platform (i.e. Stockhub Limited) does not benefit from a person engaging in investment activities in the said investment; the owner benefits from a person making better investment decisions.		In relation to the said report/communication, the communicator of the communication is anonymous, and, therefore, the purpose of the communicator, and the purpose of the communication itself, is unknown. The FCA recognises that the matter cannot be without doubt.<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref> That said, the purpose of the Stockhub platform is to help a person to make better investment decisions (i.e. it’s not lead a person to engage in investment activity). Indeed, the purpose of the platform is reflected in the platform's monetization strategy (i.e. donations). In other words, the owner of the platform (i.e. Stockhub Limited) does not benefit from a person engaging in investment activities in the said investment; the owner benefits from a person making better investment decisions.

	Accordingly, it is the view of the Stockhub company that the said investment report is NOT a financial promotion.		Accordingly, it is the view of the Stockhub company that the said investment report is NOT a financial promotion.

172.18.0.2: /* Does this investment report violate any copyright laws? */

2022-07-02T09:47:56Z

Does this investment report violate any copyright laws?

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:47, 2 July 2022
Line 21:		Line 21:
	* is the amount of the work taken reasonable and appropriate? Was it necessary to use the amount that was taken? Usually only part of a work may be used		* is the amount of the work taken reasonable and appropriate? Was it necessary to use the amount that was taken? Usually only part of a work may be used

	~~The~~ reason for using the work is to review the work itself and, ultimately, the investment to which the work relates (i.e. for review purposes), and, therefore, it is the view of Stockhub that using the work falls into the fair dealing category provided that 1) the used work is accompanied by a sufficient acknowledgement and 2) the work has been made available to the public.		On the Stockhub platform, the reason for using the work is to review the work itself and, ultimately, the investment to which the work relates (i.e. for review purposes), and, therefore, it is the view of Stockhub that using the work falls into the fair dealing category provided that 1) the used work is accompanied by a sufficient acknowledgement and 2) the work has been made available to the public.

	It is the view of Stockhub that while the offer to invest in the investment is to private members only (i.e. not to the public), the copyrighted work to which the investment relates has been made available to the public. Furthermore, it is the view of Stockhub that the acknowledgement that accompanies the used work is sufficient.		It is the view of Stockhub that while the offer to invest in the investment is to private members only (i.e. not to the public), the copyrighted work to which the investment relates has been made available to the public. Furthermore, it is the view of Stockhub that the acknowledgement that accompanies the used work is sufficient.

172.18.0.2: /* Does this investment report violate any copyright laws? */

2022-06-28T09:56:03Z

Does this investment report violate any copyright laws?

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:56, 28 June 2022
Line 25:		Line 25:
	It is the view of Stockhub that while the offer to invest in the investment is to private members only (i.e. not to the public), the copyrighted work to which the investment relates has been made available to the public. Furthermore, it is the view of Stockhub that the acknowledgement that accompanies the used work is sufficient.		It is the view of Stockhub that while the offer to invest in the investment is to private members only (i.e. not to the public), the copyrighted work to which the investment relates has been made available to the public. Furthermore, it is the view of Stockhub that the acknowledgement that accompanies the used work is sufficient.

	The main purpose of the original work is to enable people to raise funds for their companies faster, and the purpose of the new work is to enable people to make better investment decisions. Accordingly, it is the view of Stockhub that the target audience of the works and the core benefit of the works, and, ultimately, the market of the works, are significantly different. Therefore, it is also the opinion of Stockhub that using the work does not act as a substitute for the work; if anything, it acts as a complement. It's worth nothing that the price ~~to consume~~ the original work is zero (i.e. there is no fee), and, therefore, the ~~likeness~~ of the owner of the work losing revenue is zero; the owner of the work makes money from investment commissions when its clients successfully raise funds.		The main purpose of the original work is to enable people to raise funds for their companies faster, and the purpose of the new work is to enable people to make better investment decisions. Accordingly, it is the view of Stockhub that the target audience of the works and the core benefit of the works, and, ultimately, the market of the works, are significantly different. Therefore, it is also the opinion of Stockhub that using the work does not act as a substitute for the work; if anything, it acts as a complement. It's worth nothing that the price of the original work is zero (i.e. there is no fee), and, therefore, the likeliness of the owner of the work losing revenue from the Stockhub platform using the work is zero; the owner of the work makes money from investment commissions when its clients successfully raise funds.

	It is the view of Stockhub that in order to conduct an accurate review of the work (i.e. the financial promotion) and, ultimately, the investment to which the work relates (i.e. THIS), the communication of the whole work is required, and, therefore, the amount of the work taken by the communicator is reasonable and appropriate.		It is the view of Stockhub that in order to conduct an accurate review of the work (i.e. the financial promotion) and, ultimately, the investment to which the work relates (i.e. THIS), the communication of the whole work is required, and, therefore, the amount of the work taken by the communicator is reasonable and appropriate.

>Seedrs: /* Is this investment report a financial promotion? */

2022-06-27T22:17:52Z

Is this investment report a financial promotion?

← Older revision		Revision as of 23:17, 27 June 2022
Line 8:		Line 8:
	For a communication to be considered a financial promotion, the communication must contain an element of invitation or inducement, amongst other things<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/3.html</ref>; for a communication to be considered an invitation or inducement, the communication must “have the purpose or intent of leading a person to engage in investment activity".<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref>		For a communication to be considered a financial promotion, the communication must contain an element of invitation or inducement, amongst other things<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/3.html</ref>; for a communication to be considered an invitation or inducement, the communication must “have the purpose or intent of leading a person to engage in investment activity".<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref>

	Here, the communicator of the communication is anonymous, and, therefore, the purpose of the communicator, and the purpose of the communication itself, is ~~unclear~~. The FCA recognises that the matter cannot be without doubt.<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref> That said, the purpose of the Stockhub platform is to help a person to make better investment decisions (i.e. it’s not lead a person to engage in investment activity). Indeed, the purpose of the platform is reflected in the platform's monetization strategy (i.e. donations). In other words, the owner of the platform (i.e. Stockhub Limited) does not benefit from a person engaging in investment activities in the said investment; the owner benefits from a person making better investment decisions.		Here, the communicator of the communication is anonymous, and, therefore, the purpose of the communicator, and the purpose of the communication itself, is unknown. The FCA recognises that the matter cannot be without doubt.<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref> That said, the purpose of the Stockhub platform is to help a person to make better investment decisions (i.e. it’s not lead a person to engage in investment activity). Indeed, the purpose of the platform is reflected in the platform's monetization strategy (i.e. donations). In other words, the owner of the platform (i.e. Stockhub Limited) does not benefit from a person engaging in investment activities in the said investment; the owner benefits from a person making better investment decisions.

	Accordingly, it is the view of the Stockhub company that the said investment report is NOT a financial promotion.		Accordingly, it is the view of the Stockhub company that the said investment report is NOT a financial promotion.

>Seedrs: /* Is this investment report a financial promotion? */

2022-06-27T16:39:17Z

Is this investment report a financial promotion?

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:39, 27 June 2022
Line 8:		Line 8:
	For a communication to be considered a financial promotion, the communication must contain an element of invitation or inducement, amongst other things<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/3.html</ref>; for a communication to be considered an invitation or inducement, the communication must “have the purpose or intent of leading a person to engage in investment activity".<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref>		For a communication to be considered a financial promotion, the communication must contain an element of invitation or inducement, amongst other things<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/3.html</ref>; for a communication to be considered an invitation or inducement, the communication must “have the purpose or intent of leading a person to engage in investment activity".<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref>

	~~The~~ communicator of the communication is anonymous, and, therefore, the purpose of the communicator, and the purpose of the communication itself, is unclear. The FCA recognises that the matter cannot be without doubt.<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref> That said, the purpose of the Stockhub platform is to help a person to make better investment decisions (i.e. it’s not lead a person to engage in investment activity). Indeed, the purpose of the platform is reflected in the platform's monetization strategy (i.e. donations). In other words, the owner of the platform (i.e. Stockhub Limited) does not benefit from a person engaging in investment activities in the said investment; the owner benefits from a person making better investment decisions.		Here, the communicator of the communication is anonymous, and, therefore, the purpose of the communicator, and the purpose of the communication itself, is unclear. The FCA recognises that the matter cannot be without doubt.<ref>https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/PERG/8/4.html#D620</ref> That said, the purpose of the Stockhub platform is to help a person to make better investment decisions (i.e. it’s not lead a person to engage in investment activity). Indeed, the purpose of the platform is reflected in the platform's monetization strategy (i.e. donations). In other words, the owner of the platform (i.e. Stockhub Limited) does not benefit from a person engaging in investment activities in the said investment; the owner benefits from a person making better investment decisions.

	Accordingly, it is the view of the Stockhub company that the said investment report is NOT a financial promotion.		Accordingly, it is the view of the Stockhub company that the said investment report is NOT a financial promotion.